An EV or a CNG car – Which will offer a lower running cost? This has been a question for many for a long time. And today, we will be diving deep into it to know what’s best!
Attention Readers! Join us on Whatsapp Community for daily auto news updates
EV vs CNG Cars – Best Option?
For some time, CNG cars have been a better option for buyers – for its lower running costs and lower upfront cost compared to diesel and petrol cars. But it hampers the performance and only comes with a manual gearbox (except Tiago & Tigor). Similarly, EVs also have lower running costs, but offer better performance (thanks to its torquey nature). However, its upfront cost is higher, and the charging infrastructure is in the developing phase. So, which car can be a better option? Let’s take a look at a comparison between the Tata Nexon CNG and the Tata Nexon EV.
Also Read – Best Bikes To Buy Under Rs 3 Lakh!
Running Cost Explained!
Firstly, let’s head on to the math – which option offers a better running cost
| Cars | Price | Mileage / Range | CNG / EV Cost | Daily Distance | Cost Per km | Total Cost Per Day |
| Nexon CNG Creative | Rs 12.45 lakh (on-road, Mumbai) | 20 km/kg Approx | Rs 77/kg | 40km | Rs 3.85 | Rs 154 |
| Nexon EV Creative 45 | Rs 14.77 lakh (on-road, Mumbai) | 350 km | Rs 22/kWh (Jio BP)* | 40km | Rs 2.86 | Rs 114 |
| Nexon EV Creative 45 (Using Home Charging) | Rs 14.77 lakh (on-road, Mumbai)# | 350 km | Rs 13/kWh^ | 40km | Rs 1.66 | Rs 67 |
*Jio BP price may vary depending on cities.
#Home Charger should be purchased separately from the manufacturer (cost not included in the table)
^The electricity price might differ from city to city, we took an example from Mumbai. (Adani supplier, unit slab – 301 to 500kW)
Also Read – Hyundai’s Plan To Trouble Tata Nexon Accidentally Revealed?
EV vs CNG Cars – So Is EV Better?
From the above table, one can easily say that EV is a better option. But, we must keep in mind its extra upfront cost.
In the above example, the EV model comes with an extra cost of Rs 2.32 lakh over CNG model.
Considering the daily drive & electricity cost, you will come at a breakeven point in 16 years with public charging & 7 years with home charger. So, the EVs don’t make sense, right? But wait, there’s something more.
Also Read – Only Creta Rival With Mercedes Feature Launching Next Month!
EV vs CNG Cars – Service Cost
In the game of servicing, the EVs are the clear winners. In a CNG model, your maintenance costs will be higher due to engine oil, brake fluid, clutch, filters and other fluids. Additionally, the cost increases going forward if there is an issue with even a small part of the engine or gearbox. EVs don’t have any of these components, and also it comes with 15 year warranty (Nexon EV 45 example) – which means all major parts are covered till the life of the car.
Comparing between Nexon CNG and Nexon EV (home-charging)
| Cars | Total Running Cost Per km (fuel / electricity) | Maintenance Cost Per Year (average) | Running After 7 Years | Maintenance Cost For First 7 Years | Maintenance Cost Per km | Total Running Cost (fuel + maintenance) Per km | Total Cost After 7 Years |
| Nexon CNG | Rs 3.85 | Rs 10,000 | 1,00,800km | Rs 70,000 | Rs 0.70 | Rs 4.55 | Rs 4,57,632 |
| Nexon EV | Rs 1.66 | Rs 3,000 | 1,00,800km | Rs 21,000 | Rs 0.21 | Rs 1.87 | Rs 1,88,496 |
Above mentioned figures are only a rough approximation
Over a 7-year ownership period, the Nexon EV finally overtakes the CNG version in total cost of ownership, saving you ₹37,136 in the long run.
Also Read – Rs 15 Lakh Most Powerful Skoda Is Here!
Why To Buy An EV
- Low service and running cost
- Environment friendly
- Superior performance
- Convenience of automatic
- Silent cabin experience
Also Read – Top 5 Cars Under Rs 15 Lakh!
Why Buy A CNG?
Well, looking at the above data, why should you buy a CNG?
Related Posts
- New Hyundai Venue To Get India’s Favourite Engine? » MotorOctane
- Spend Less On Bike Mods & Get These 5 Important Things! » MotorOctane
- Only Way To Save Your Car From E20! » MotorOctane
- 3 New Mahindra XUV700 Rivals Launching Soon! » MotorOctane
- 3 New Mahindra XUV700 Rivals Launching Soon! » MotorOctane
Hello friends, my name is Manoj Meena, and I’m a BA Final Year student. I have a deep passion for writing biographies because, in Hindi, there’s often a lack of detailed information about notable individuals. To bridge this gap, I collect extensive information and write biographies about popular personalities. I love sharing their stories and inspiring others through my work. You can also follow me on Instagram and Facebook to stay updated with my latest biographies and content. Connect with me to explore the fascinating lives of influential people!